Skip to content
PickEasy

PickEasy Awards 2026

Best Italian restaurants in Montreal

Five Italian restaurants in Montreal, with the lists that name them and why. Five have made Canada's 100 Best and two were named best new restaurants.

Four of these five Italian rooms pour natural or natural-leaning wine. Pasta Pooks grew out of a pop-up and now makes its pasta by hand each morning, with agnolotti del plin and tiramisù among the dishes the lists single out. Paloma is a family affair of about 30 seats, where a chef father and his sommelier daughter cook from their French and Niçoise Italian roots, down to the trippa.

Three of the five come from one team. Nora Gray is the low-lit, wood-panelled room in Little Burgundy where Emma Cardarelli cooks regional Italian food and Ryan Gray runs a list of mostly natural wines; the name joins her grandmother's first name to his surname. The same team is behind Gia Vin & Grill, wood-fired cooking and natural wine in an old garage, and Elena, a Saint-Henri pizzeria with a three-level patio. Three of the five are on the 2026 edition of Canada's 100 Best. Montreal's French restaurants have a page of their own.

Map of Montreal with the picks numbered in order: 1. Pasta Pooks, 2. Paloma, 3. Gia Vin & Grill, 4. Nora Gray, 5. Elena
  1. Pasta Pooks

    Handmade pasta · Montréal · $$

    Pasta made by hand each morning.

    More on Pasta Pooks
  2. Website preview: giagiagia.com100 Best#71

    Gia Vin & Grill

    Italian · Montréal · $$

    Wood-fired Italian and natural wine in an old garage.

    More on Gia Vin & Grill
  3. 4

    Nora Gray

    Regional Italian · Little Burgundy, Montréal

    Low-lit, wood-panelled room for regional Italian and mostly natural wines.

    More on Nora Gray

More of the best in Montreal

Everything in Montreal