Skip to content
PickEasy

PickEasy Awards 2026

Best Italian restaurants in Toronto

Five Italian restaurants in Toronto, with the lists that name them and why. Three hold a MICHELIN star, one is in the MICHELIN Guide, five have made Canada's 100 Best and two were named best new restaurants.

Italian cooking in Toronto goes high, in one case to the 38th floor. Don Alfonso 1890 looks over the harbour while Davide Ciavattella pairs local plates with dishes from the original on the Amalfi Coast, wild-rose-scented tagliatelle with eel gelato among them. On College Street, DaNico fills an early-1900s bank building and keeps its wine in the old vault. Daniele Corona's cooking placed third on the 2026 50 Top Italy world list, and both rooms hold a MICHELIN star.

Giulietta and Osteria Giulia are siblings. The first is a Dufferin Grove room where staff make every guest feel like a regular, known for octopus poached and then crisped in the wood oven. The second, in Yorkville, cooks the seafood of Liguria, with Cetara anchovies over whipped butter and a starred kitchen. Bar Prima centres on a six-seat bar in the middle of the room, where lobster fra diavola leads a menu of Italian classics with new spins. Canada's 100 Best compares DaNico's refinement to kaiseki; for kaiseki itself, see the best Japanese restaurants in Toronto.

Map of Toronto with the picks numbered in order: 1. DaNico, 2. Giulietta, 3. Osteria Giulia, 4. Don Alfonso 1890, 5. Bar Prima
  1. Website preview: danicotoronto.comMICHELIN1 MICHELIN Star

    DaNico

    Italian fine dining · Little Italy (College Street) · $$$$

    Daniele Corona's Italian prix fixe and eight-course menus, in an old bank building.

    More on DaNico
  2. Giulietta

    Italian · Toronto · $$$

    Octopus poached, then crisped in the wood oven.

    More on Giulietta
  3. Osteria Giulia

    Ligurian Italian, seafood · Yorkville · $$$$

    Rob Rossi cooks Ligurian seafood; serious wine and cocktails alongside.

    More on Osteria Giulia
  4. Photo: Silver Dovelet · CC BY-SA 3.0MICHELIN1 MICHELIN Star
    4

    Don Alfonso 1890

    Italian tasting menu · Harbourfront · $$$$

    Davide Ciavattella's eight courses, high up, pair local plates with ones from the Amalfi original.

    More on Don Alfonso 1890
  5. 5

    Bar Prima

    Italian · Toronto

    Lobster fra diavola, and a six-seat bar mid-room.

    More on Bar Prima

More of the best in Toronto

Everything in Toronto