Five Italian restaurants in Toronto, with the lists that name them and why. Three hold a MICHELIN star, one is in the MICHELIN Guide, five have made Canada's 100 Best and two were named best new restaurants.
Italian cooking in Toronto goes high, in one case to the 38th floor. Don Alfonso 1890 looks over the harbour while Davide Ciavattella pairs local plates with dishes from the original on the Amalfi Coast, wild-rose-scented tagliatelle with eel gelato among them. On College Street, DaNico fills an early-1900s bank building and keeps its wine in the old vault. Daniele Corona's cooking placed third on the 2026 50 Top Italy world list, and both rooms hold a MICHELIN star.
Giulietta and Osteria Giulia are siblings. The first is a Dufferin Grove room where staff make every guest feel like a regular, known for octopus poached and then crisped in the wood oven. The second, in Yorkville, cooks the seafood of Liguria, with Cetara anchovies over whipped butter and a starred kitchen. Bar Prima centres on a six-seat bar in the middle of the room, where lobster fra diavola leads a menu of Italian classics with new spins. Canada's 100 Best compares DaNico's refinement to kaiseki; for kaiseki itself, see the best Japanese restaurants in Toronto.
A former early-1900s bank building with dark, luxurious decor and wine kept in the vault, with polished but relaxed service. The Italian cooking uses global flavours skillfully, in multicourse and tasting formats.
Standout dishes: soft-boiled egg with tonburi caviar, tomato confit risotto with braised lamb shoulder
A lavish dining room in a historic bank building serving Italian fine dining, with a refinement compared to kaiseki and an emphasis on local Ontario produce.
Standout dishes: pigeon breast with nasturtium foam, amaebi crudo, spaghettoni in Ontario mushroom extract, Ibaraki crown melon dessert
The reviewer singled out great technique, clean flavors and elegant presentations in contemporary Italian cooking, plus a high-level wine list and formal but relaxed service.
Standout dishes: mussels cacio e pepe, Gragnano spaghetti with mushrooms and truffle, black cod with vermouth and caviar, bosco delle fragole
Chef Daniele Corona was credited with a tasteful, authentic fine dining experience in the elegant setting of a former bank, backed by a cellar of top Italian labels.
The owners' first restaurant keeps its charms with carefully made new-school Italian classics, strong cocktail and wine lists, and warm, professional service.
A dependable neighbourhood restaurant in Dufferin Grove where staff make every guest feel like a regular. The kitchen gets the most from each dish, and the pizza is satisfying.
Standout dishes: yellowfin tuna crudo with bergamot marmalade, ricotta agnolotti with morels, mafalde with veal cheek ragu
A consistently pleasant, well-run room focused on Ligurian seafood traditions that set it apart from typical Italian menus. The wine list and cocktail program add to a polished, hospitable meal.
Standout dishes: vitello tonnato, Ligurian flatbread with stracchino, snow crab tagliolini with bottarga, tiramisu
The more polished sibling of Giulietta, focused on Ligurian cooking with a strong seafood emphasis, in a pale minimalist room with an Italian-focused wine list and professional service.
Standout dishes: vitello tonnato, paccheri alla Genovese, Cetara anchovies over whipped butter, trofie al pesto
The reviewer valued tasty starters and satisfying pastas, with particular skill in cooking and dressing fresh pasta, attentive service and a welcoming room, inspired by chef Rob Rossi's Ligurian roots.
Credited for an impressive wine list of native grapes and artisan producers, an original by-the-glass selection, and elegant, minimalist interiors in natural wood.
Standout dishes: piccage pagilia e fieno, grilled rack of lamb
A dependable choice for dates, family dinners or client meetings, with a sophisticated Italian menu in set and tasting formats. The hotel-top views are a bonus to the food.
A harbour-view dining room where chef Davide Ciavattella serves an eight-course tasting menu with whimsical presentation, drawing on local ingredients and dishes from the original Amalfi Coast restaurant.
Standout dishes: wild-rose-scented tagliatelle with eel gelato
The reviewer valued the 38th-floor room with its view and attentive staff, and a Mediterranean approach focused on pasta, with restrained, pure execution that respects the ingredient.
Craig Harding and Julian D'Ippolito pair traditional Italian classics with small plates built around seasonal ingredients, in a warm room worth dressing up for.
Standout dishes: tenderloin Rossini, lobster fra diavola, spaghetti all'amatriciana